RSS
Email
SMS
Online Advertising - 5 Reasons why Behavioral Targeting might not work in India
(Rate this article)
Loading ...Email It!
Recently there was some buzz about a Porn Banner Ad appearing on Rediff…
The ad was something to do with ‘intimate college girls’ and the user was actually reading an article about GRE and colleges abroad.
Is that contextual advertising? Perhaps to some extent it is.
There was a comment in the linked post where someone mentioned that a particular Ad network was serving these Ads. Though it might be a baseless rumour – it can’t be ignored.
This could be contextual advertising – but could this also be linked to behavioral targeting?
Online ad network company Komli Media is now offering behavioral targeting capabilities to its advertisers.
Eg: This will initially track users visiting travel sites and then target them with travel advertisements regardless of the type of site the users visit.
So a student looking up information about colleges will possibly be served ‘college’ related ads?
How can this be possible?
Your behaviour can either be tracked when you reveal your intentions or interests on a Web site, which is tracking data OR advertising can be targeted by using an adware installed on your computer.
Recently we blogged about Yahoo’s Behavioral Targeting solution SmartAds. i.e., the ability to serve online advertisements to the people who are most like to respond to them.
Let’s face it – Internet advertising can be very annoying. Nasty pop-ads and flashy banner ads almost seem to be everywhere. Worse, these omnipresent ads, rarely contain content of interest to the viewer.
Behavioral Targeting is definitely the future of Online Advertising, but let us look at some points which could be plaguing its growth in India?
- Lack of enough Paying Customers:
It’s not really a co-incidence that Komli mentioned or chose the ‘travel’ domain to start of the service. Travel is a completely revenue driven domain and one of the prime drivers of e-transactions in India. IRCTC (Indian Railways) is our country’s largest E-Commerce driver. Travel sees an enormous amount of online consumers. But users are still uncomfortable at the thought of making other regular purchases online.
I would still do all my pre-purchase research of an Electronic gadget online – and prefer buying it offline. Unless the price advantage online is huge (Which is not currently so).Behavioral targeting can be used to a certain extent for classifieds – but if a user is surfing a matrimony website, wouldn’t he already know of that particular site? Or would you track this behaviour of his and when he’s on some other site in your network – show him the advertisement of a rival matrimony site?
- Lack of Advertisers:
Behavioral Targeting will work wonders for local advertisers.
If I’m searching for information about a Vacuum Cleaner and you show me the ad of the nearest shop to my place which sells it – Perfect.
But how many local shops, restaurants etc currently use the Online medium?Then again – franchisee outlets wouldn’t want to advertise on a national level. Would companies looking at mere foot-falls and brand awareness benefit? Often it’s the unpredictability and the curiosity which a banner creates, which is the main reason it results in a click-through.
Behavioral Targeting would ensure greater ROI for the clients. It would also mean genuine leads, but it would also mean lesser prospective numbers for Marketing Managers to show to their bosses. Agencies would have to sacrifice some income as volumes of banner impressions would be lesser for targeted ads.
Currently we are in a phase, where everyone is on a customer and number acquisition spree. The value and engagement is something almost everyone is keeping aside for the future.
- Massive popularity of Cyber Cafes:
comScore put the current Online Indian Internet population at 22 million.
IAMAI put it at around 40 million last year and said is set to grow to a 100 million by 2007-08.
JuxtConsult puts it at 30 million (April 2007).
Something somewhere is going wrong? Huge deviation of figures! 10 million is no joke!
Is it because multiple users are using the same internet connection? Massive popularity of cyber café’s? Multiple connection users (Accessing from Work, Home, Public Wi-Fi spots, GPRS etc)? - User Backlash:
Would I really be comfortable if I knew someone is tracking my surfing trends?
Google was ranked the worst when it came to handling a user’s privacy.It’s a very fine line between invading a user’s privacy and serving him better. Currently getting contextual ads might not appeal to users as a benefit.
- Behaviour? :
What exactly is online behaviour? Does visiting an online travel site – label me as a traveler? Does it mean I’m going to travel all the time? Showing me travel ads all the time won’t really be the smartest of moves – because chances are that if I am a regular traveler, I’d already know about your service and by the time you show me your ad - I might have already booked my tickets.Behaviour targeting should be used in sync with user demographics – display of related linked products. Link regular business travelers to a smart phone, executive clothing etc.
But is there any Ad Network in India this huge? Except for perhaps Google?
Behaviourial Targeting is an exciting concept – but ours is a nation where a company chooses to spam 1 Lakh people and hope for converts rather than reaching out to a few 100 ‘targeted’ guys.
Possible future of Behavioral Targeting in India?
Mobile Advertising. The Mobile Operators are the ones who can really exploit this. They know me – They know who I talk to. Who I send messages to. What kind of wallpapers I download. What kind of music I like (Caller back tunes) etc etc.
Soon with the advent of Local Search on mobile – they’ll know what kind of restaurants I go to, what kind of movies I see…
Behaviour mapping?
Feel free to share your views with us.
Here’s an article I’d recommend reading if you are looking for some US figures.
Loading ...
Jan 21, 2008
Looking in retrospect, what you mentioned in July 2007 and gave 5 reasons of why behavioural ads may not work, this post is in contradiction to itself.
On one hand you are saying behviour based ads are not got on other hand you say placing ads to 1 Lakh people is incorrect?
I think behaviour based ads are targetted to a round 1 qualified audience. So once the funnel gets further qualified you can place more qualified ads.
The 5 reasons you gave are not strong enough to hold people from going for behavioural ads. And you go on saying “Targetted Ads” to 100 people which is part of behavioural advertising. So probably you might have meant the present way of behavioural ads is not correct. I wrote some time back on Targetted Ads.
http://sachinuppal.blogspot.com/2007/08/targetted-marketing-top-5-ways-for.html
Lack of paying customers? - R u serious?
Cost difference in online and offline purchase definitely plays important role, however, think of company’s expenditure getting reduced, I would give you a low price if you buy online.
Anyways, I like the point made for Mobile ads and that’s for sure going to dominate 2009 and 2010 ad spends.
As well as from Branding perspective, companies who sustain their online ad and sales programs in 2007-08 are the ones who would reap benefits in 2009-10 as they would have made an association with people for online sales channel.
Looking forward to a mobile future!
BTW:- Gmail captured 25% of the email market even when they are accused of not respecting privacy. So how important is privacy anyways? Give me relevant content and I wouldn’t complain!